Lucas is forced to choose between Brooke and Peyton when both show interest in him. Meanwhile, after the fallout of Nathan's collapse on court and other issues plaguing the team, Whitey cancels practice to force the team to refocus. With no practice, Dan takes Nathan on a father-son weekend in order to try to make-up with both his son and Deb; and Deb and Haley work together to organize an open-mic night at the cafe.